Wow, I hope my story doesn’t seem like I’m trying to stop anyone from doing anything. If nothing else I hope reading my story is empowering to others!

Also I’ve never heard of the “old green wire” problem, maybe you can add some details if it might help others?

I think you mean Matter over Thread?

I personally don’t have a Matter network at home but I run some Aqua ZigBee stuff and it works well.

I recall a while back Ecobee was blocking Home Assistant users, apparently by locking down api access.

A quick search tells me that they now have an official integration and are good with Home Assistant again.

That is truly good news! I had previously written this company off for being hostile to self-hosters but apparently have cleared their name.

Good luck! I imagine it will be really satisfying to restore full function and keep your data out of Google’s hands.

I agree and I’ve always tried to keep WiFi IoT devices to an absolute minimum. I have a couple dozen ZigBee devices that have been rock solid, and if my count is right I have 6 on the WiFi IoT network.

• Lay-Z-Spa smart control built on an Esp32
• A vintage fan that I replaced the internals including an Esp32 for remote control
• Two WLED Esp32 controllers
• A Govee controller
• And now the Nest

This feels like a reasonable number, and being mostly based on reliable Esp32 boards helps. With that said, I would absolutely urge anyone adding smart home equipment to look into ZigBee, ZWave, Thread or some combination.

My Zigbee devices have been reliable and have very low latency which is really important for things like lights / switches.

Good luck! We are on day 3 with it and it has been reliably following the schedule and responding to temporary overrides as expected.

Thanks for reading! I see posts like this every now and again and always wanted a reason to do one for myself. I’ve also been itching to be less of a lurker and make some posts here.

Great question and the answer is a combination of things. First, I got an absolute great deal on it, just $25 shipped. Second, I knew the hardware itself was really high quality. And lastly, I don’t have a zwave radio in my home (this far) and looking at the ZigBee thermostats seemed like a bit of a minefield. I do mention in the blog post that I was considering a Zen ZigBee thermostat and then when I found the super cheap Nest decided it was worth a try even if I later replace it.

Nice luck on the A/C upgrade! I’ll never I understand why a house this modern skipped out on running a 5+ wire cable.

There was some research recently that showed the same thing. People who are “dug in” on a topic, usually a political topic, will shut down when a person tries to persuade them of an alternative, but are much more open to hear the same arguments from AI and actually reconsider their position.

I believe this is a big reason why X-Ai was so important for conservatives to get off of the ground, they were afraid all the crazy would start wearing off if people asked the “woke” models for the truth.

The recent Hardware Haven video I think was better that the LTT videos. That dude does a great job presenting some pros and cons and is much more level headed in his approach.

But I agree that the big names in YT is doing a good thing showing people it’s not too hard to switch, Especially if you have a spare SSD so you can keep your Windows install just in case.